LET'S TALK

When a Recruiter Calls, Will Your Best People Stay

Episode 34 Featuring Scott Love | President, The Attorney Search Group

Right now, someone is talking to your best people, and you are not in the room. Recruiters are reaching top performers more often than they ever have, and most leaders still assume the people they count on stay for the pay, the title, or the name on the building. Scott Love knows how wrong that assumption is, because he is the person those people call when they are ready to leave.

As a recruiter who places corporate and finance partners at global law firms, Scott sits in the exit chair and hears the reasons people never say out loud to their own leadership, and across this conversation with host Kim Bohr he lays them out plainly. They do not trust their leaders. They are afraid a colleague will steal a client they bring in. They do not believe pay is fair. And when he asks the ones who refuse to leave why they stay, the answer is never money. It is that they do not want to let their team down.

Listen

🎧 LISTEN, Hear Scott Love’s Full Conversation

Want the full episode? Listen to Scott Love on Courage to Advance, where he and host Kim Bohr get into why your best people really leave, the headhunter call test, and how to build trust before you need it.

Right now, someone is talking to your best people, and you are not in the room. Recruiters are reaching top performers more often than they ever have, and most leaders still assume the people they count on stay for the pay, the title, or the name on the building. Scott Love knows how wrong that assumption is, because he is the person those people call when they are ready to leave.

As a recruiter who places corporate and finance partners at global law firms, Scott sits in the exit chair and hears the reasons people never say out loud to their own leadership, and across this conversation with host Kim Bohr he lays them out plainly. They do not trust their leaders. They are afraid a colleague will steal a client they bring in. They do not believe pay is fair. And when he asks the ones who refuse to leave why they stay, the answer is never money. It is that they do not want to let their team down.

What You’ll Discover 

  • Why top performers almost never leave over pay, and what actually makes them stay
  • The headhunter call test that tells you whether your best person is already halfway out the door
  • Why the most powerful retention tool costs nothing, and how to give recognition so it lands
  • What emotional equity is, and how to give people an ownership stake without handing out equity
  • The real reasons people quit that they will tell a recruiter but never tell their own leadership
  • How to build trust before you need it, using the trust funnel Scott runs in his own practice
  • The self awareness exercise that made one leader change course in a single moment
  • Why the market for your best people is more competitive than it has ever been

Episode Highlights 

[00:00] The conversation you are never in. Kim opens on the quiet reality that someone is always talking to your best people, and introduces Scott Love, the person they call when they are ready to go.

[08:35] What partners say on their way out. Scott shares the real reasons top performers leave, the ones they never tell their own firm, from distrust of leaders to the fear that colleagues will steal their clients.

[09:59] It is never about the money. Scott on why the people who stay never cite pay, and the headhunter call test every leader should run on their best people.

[16:10] Emotional equity, defined. Scott explains how to give people an ownership stake without stock, from the force multiplier project to a receptionist who became indispensable.

[24:32] Building a trust funnel. Scott breaks down the roughly seventeen moves he makes to earn trust before he needs it, borrowed from a realtor who stays useful instead of pushy.

[32:32] What courage to advance means to Scott. Scott closes on facing adversity and using it as an advantage, and on how fear dissipates the moment you walk toward it.

Key Takeaways for HR Leaders 

  1. People stay for trust and significance, not for pay. When Scott asks why someone will not leave, the answer is never the paycheck, it is that they do not want to let their team down. Audit what your culture actually rewards, and build recognition and ownership into the everyday, because that is what holds your best people.
  2. The decision to stay or go is made long before the recruiter calls. By the time your top performer takes the call, they already know what they will say. Run the headhunter call test on your best people now, and fix what the honest answer reveals rather than waiting for the resignation.
  3. Recognition is the cheapest retention tool you have, and most leaders underuse it. Name the specific thing a person did, out loud, in front of their colleagues. A vague thanks wears thin fast, but being genuinely seen is what makes someone feel indispensable to the team.
  4. Give people a stake and they defend what they helped build. Emotional equity does not require stock. Hand your best people the high stakes project early and visibly, and the ownership that follows turns an employee into a champion who stays.

About Our Guest

Scott Love is the president of The Attorney Search Group, where he recruits corporate and finance partners for global law firms and facilitates law firm mergers. He is a graduate of the United States Naval Academy and a former Surface Warfare Officer, and he started in recruiting in 1995, long before the field moved online.

He is the host and producer of The Rainmaking Podcast, a top 2% show, the author of Why They Follow, and coauthor of Rainmaker Confidential. He has been quoted in the Wall Street Journal, Forbes, The American Lawyer, Bloomberg, Above the Law, Huffington Post, and dozens of business publications across the globe.

Through his writing, podcast, and speaking, Scott teaches professionals to become rainmakers who get the call from high margin clients. In this episode he turns that lens around, to the leaders trying to keep the rainmakers they already have.

Connect with Scott Love

Notable Quotes 

Scott Love: “It’s never about how much they’re paid. It’s never about the status of the organization.”

Scott Love: “Face your fear. It’s just imaginary. When you walk forward, fear dissipates like a mist.”

Kim Bohr: “There’s a conversation happening right now about your best people, and you will never be in the room for it.”

Kim Bohr: “It’s the real authenticity that fuels people to realize, like, oh, I really am seen and valued for my work.”

Related Resources 

About Courage to Advance 

Courage to Advance explores how visionary leaders are building the organizations they wish existed, companies that prove business doesn’t have to be dehumanizing. Hosted by Kim Bohr, President and COO of SparkEffect, each episode features executives who refuse to accept that traditional corporate practices are inevitable, sharing the experiments, resistance, and breakthrough results of choosing human flourishing alongside business success. 

Subscribe anywhere you listen to podcasts. You can find links to all platforms HERE! 

Visit: https://sparkeffect.com/sparkeffect-podcast-courage-to-advance/ for free resources and tools. 

Receive New Podcast Episodes in Your Inbox

CourageToAdvance_PodcastCov_Season2_1080

Recommended reading

Episode 13: Featuring Calli Bakken, Founder of Wiggle Work & Interim Executive Director, Matthew’s Voice Project Here’s a...

Episode 36: Featuring Jess Dewell | Strategic Growth Advisor, Red Direction Your leadership team agreed. Everyone nodded, the...

Episode 36: Featuring Jess Dewell | Strategic Growth Advisor, Red Direction Most leaders are still treating disruption like...

Five Bold Predictions for HR in 2027 (and What to Do About Them)
A 60-minute THRIVE Learning Session on the five shifts most likely to shape leadership, retention and restructuring decisions...